| Name | Score | Price | City |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bricks & Barley | 8.9 | $15.82 | NOTL |
| Garage Pizza | 8.8 | $22.60 | NOTL |
| Petrullo Marketplace | 8.4 | $17.50 | St. Davids |
| Pieza Pizza & Vino | 8.3 | $22.60 | NOTL |
| Ravine Vineyard Estate Winery | 8.3 | $28.25 | St. Davids |
| Ruffino's Pasta Bar & Grill | 8.2 | $23.73 | NOTL |
| The Old Winery Restaurant & Wine Bar | 8.1 | $15.82 | NOTL |
| The Grist Craft Brewery & Kitchen | 7.9 | $16.95 | NOTL |
| The Pie Plate Bakery Café | 7.9 | $8.98 | Virgil |
| Italian Pizza and Subs | 7.7 | $12.71 | Virgil |
| Niagara on the Lake Golf Club | 7.7 | $16.95 | NOTL |
| Nina Gelateria & Pastry Shop | 7.5 | $14.70 | NOTL |
| Butler's Bar and Grill | 7.3 | $15.82 | NOTL |
| Colaneri Estate Winery | 7.1 | $18.00 | NOTL |
| Two Sisters Vineyards | 6.8 | $24.86 | NOTL |
| Bistro Six One | 6.6 | $16.94 | NOTL |
| Domino's Pizza Brooklyn Style | 5.9 | $14.68 | NOTL |
| Sandtrap Pub & Grill | 5.8 | $21.35 | NOTL |
| Wayne Gretzky Estates | 3.3 | $24.86 | NOTL |
| Pizza Pizza Superfood Crust | 2.6 | $16.60 | NOTL |
| Pillitteri Estates Winery | 0 | $0.00 | NOTL |